To celebrate a landmark 60th birthday, singer Wendy Scherl returned— after too long an absence to the stage of Don’t Tell Mama where she had made her cabaret debut in 1989—with The Beat Goes On, a solid, entertaining retrospective of songs from her years of cabaret shows. For the occasion she engaged the musical talents of a veritable Mount Rushmore of cabaret accompanists—Tom Hubbard on bass, Ron Tierno on drums, and music director/ arranger Christopher Denny on piano. Director Barry Kleinbort kept things tight and focused and flowing.  

The singer was obviously there to have a good time, and she succeeded. In her opener, “Raise the Roof” (Andrew Lippa, from The Wild Party), Scherl savored each delicious lyric. A beautifully low-key, touching, very personal “Fallin’” (Marvin Hamlisch, Carol Bayer Sager, from They’re Playing Our Song), changed the energy and revealed she had lost none of her storytelling magic. A bubbly, if inconsequential “The Lady is a Tramp” (Richard Rodgers, Lorenz Hart, from Babes in Arms), was followed by a charming paean to her former home with “New York Romance” (Rusty McGee), a pleasing collage of images of the city.  

Revealing her love for ’60s movie musicals, she transformed the camp classic, “Where the Boys Are” (Neil Sedaka, Howard Greenfield), into a heartwarming, gentle expression of love, longing, and romance. It was so good that the addition of the Gershwin’s “Someone to Watch Over Me” in medley diminished its effectiveness. It was a shame, given the brilliance of Denny’s arrangement and Scherl’s phrasing. On the other hand, a medley of Cole Porter’s “Anything Goes” smartly led into Sonny Bono’s “The Beat Goes On,” creating a canny and invigorating expansion of both songs into a single message that fit perfectly in her exploration of change and the passage of time.  

Given her absence from the cabaret scene, she might well be forgiven for the inclusion of Bob Dylan’s “To Make You Feel My Love,” a song that seems to turn up in every other cabaret show lately.  (A message to all singers—Dylan did write other songs!) To make up for this, without realizing it, Scherl included “Rita’s Turn” (Marvin Hamlisch, Craig Carnelia, from Sweet Smell of Success) which proved to be a sparkling highlight of the evening. The inclusion of an ill-advised, long-due for retirement, “Making Whoopee” (Walter Donaldson, Gus Kahn), and an ill-suited, not-quite-right-for-her-voice “The World Goes ‘Round” (John Kander, Fred Ebb), caused the evening to drag. I would have much preferred a few more surprises, like “Rita’s Turn,” or maybe an acknowledgement of more contemporary material as a change of pace even if it would have been off concept. 

While those changes might have made the show better, what Scherl offered was more than okay.  Two “wrap up” choices at the end brought the audience back to full appreciation of her strong personal connection with her material and the unique blend of musicianship and storytelling that has always been her trademark. Perhaps she should make a birthday visit to Don’t Tell Mama an annual event.

### 

Presented at Don’t Tell Mama, 343 W. 46th St., NYC, on October 8, 2026.